Smithtown to Purchase Historic St. James Calderone Theater: A Complex Decision

Introduction

The Town of Smithtown is considering purchasing the historic St. James Calderone Theater, a move that has sparked both excitement and controversy. Proponents of the purchase argue that it would preserve a valuable piece of local history and provide a much-needed cultural hub for the community. Opponents, however, raise concerns about the cost of the purchase and upkeep, as well as the potential for noise and traffic issues.

This trending news article will critically examine the complexities of the decision facing Smithtown. We will explore the various perspectives on the issue, present data points and real-life examples to add depth, and engage with relevant journal research, news articles, and other credible sources.

Arguments in Favor of the Purchase

Supporters of the purchase argue that the St. James Calderone Theater is a valuable historical asset that should be preserved for future generations. The theater was built in 1925 and has hosted countless performances over the years, including Broadway shows, concerts, and lectures. It is one of the few remaining historic theaters on Long Island, and its purchase would ensure its continued existence.

In addition to its historical value, the theater would also provide a much-needed cultural hub for the community. Smithtown does not currently have a dedicated performing arts space, and the Calderone Theater would fill this void. It would provide a venue for local theater groups, musical ensembles, and other performing artists. It would also host educational programs and workshops, enriching the cultural life of the community.

Arguments Against the Purchase

Opponents of the purchase raise several concerns, including the cost of the purchase and upkeep, as well as the potential for noise and traffic issues. The theater is currently owned by a private developer, who is asking $5 million for the property. The Town of Smithtown would also need to invest in renovations and ongoing maintenance costs, which could add up to millions more.

In addition to the financial concerns, opponents also worry about the potential for noise and traffic issues. The theater is located in a residential area, and some residents are concerned that it will bring noise and traffic congestion to their neighborhood. They also worry that the theater will be used for late-night events, which could disrupt their sleep.

Analysis

The decision facing Smithtown is a complex one, with valid arguments on both sides. The Town Board must weigh the potential benefits of the purchase, such as preserving a historic landmark and providing a cultural hub for the community, against the potential costs and drawbacks, such as the cost of the purchase and upkeep, and the potential for noise and traffic issues.

One way to mitigate the concerns of opponents would be to create a community advisory board to oversee the operation of the theater. This board could be responsible for developing a noise and traffic management plan, and for ensuring that the theater is used in a way that is compatible with the surrounding neighborhood.

Conclusion

The Town of Smithtown is facing a difficult decision in whether or not to purchase the St. James Calderone Theater. There are valid arguments on both sides of the issue, and the Town Board must carefully weigh the potential benefits and drawbacks before making a decision.

If the Town Board does decide to purchase the theater, it is important to create a comprehensive plan for its operation. This plan should include a noise and traffic management plan, and should ensure that the theater is used in a way that is compatible with the surrounding neighborhood.

The purchase of the St. James Calderone Theater could be a valuable investment in the future of Smithtown. It could help to preserve a historic landmark, provide a much-needed cultural hub for the community, and create economic opportunities. However, it is important to carefully consider the potential costs and drawbacks before making a decision.

Read also: Lisa Frank Documentary